You might have questions like “what is the difference between primary and secondary hypothyroidism?” or “what causes primary or secondary hypothyroidism?” if you’ve been diagnosed with thyroid dysfunction. The answer to that question gives you a better understanding of your symptoms and underscores why the standard approach of prescribing levothyroxine might not work for you. 

The vast majority of thyroid dysfunction is caused by issues within the thyroid gland itself, but in rare cases, the problem starts in the pituitary gland, creating a diagnostic puzzle that requires more than a simple TSH test to solve. 

Let’s dissect the main causes of primary hypothyroidism vs secondary hypothyroidism, and examine why confusing the two can lead to patients suffering as they fall through care gaps. 

The Thyroid System: It’s All About the Feedback Loop

The butterfly-shaped thyroid gland in the neck is primarily tasked with producing the Thyroxine (T4) and Triiodothyronine (T3) hormones, which help regulate metabolism. The pituitary gland at the base of the brain helps to manage the thyroid gland by sending out the Thyroid-Stimulating Hormone (TSH), which is essentially a “work harder” directive to the thyroid gland. 

The entire system is called the Hypothalamic-Pituitary-Thyroid (HPT) Axis, and it’s a fine-tuned feedback loop:

• The hypothalamus (in the brain) releases Thyrotropin-Releasing Hormone (TRH).
• TRH tells the pituitary to release TSH.
• TSH tells the thyroid to produce T4 and T3.
• Rising levels of T4/T3 then flow back to the pituitary and hypothalamus, signalling them to slow down TSH and TRH production.

It’s usually an efficient process, but the U.S. medical system has dangerously oversimplified it into a single metric: TSH. Conventional wisdom goes that if TSH levels are high, the thyroid gland is underproducing T4 (and thus causing hypothyroidism). The problem with this simplification is that this idea fails when facing questions, such as what if the thyroid gland is underproducing T4 and T3 because the pituitary gland isn’t working correctly, or what if T4 and T3 levels remain normal while TSH is slightly high or even fairly high as the body struggles to balance against the onslaught of excess iodine intake? 

Primary Hypothyroidism: When the Thyroid Gland Fails

Primary hypothyroidism is the most common form of hypothyroidism and occurs when the source of dysfunction originates in the thyroid gland. The gland becomes unable to produce adequate quantities of T4, regardless of the amount of TSH the pituitary gland sends out to stimulate hormone production. 

Primary Hypothyroidism Causes: What Makes the Thyroid Stop Working?

Some common causes of damage to the thyroid gland include:

• Autoimmune attack (Hashimoto's Thyroiditis): This is the reported top cause of thyroid dysfunction in iodine-sufficient countries like the U.S. It’s the result of the immune system wrongly identifying the thyroid gland as a foreign object and attacking it, leading to inflammation that damages functional tissues over time. Excessive iodine intake is a potential cause of thyroid autoimmunity. 
• Medical interventions: Procedures like thyroid surgery, where the thyroid gland is partially or completely removed, or radioactive iodine treatment for conditions such as hyperthyroidism or cancer, can cause primary hypothyroidism. 
• Medications: Drugs like lithium (prescribed for mental health issues such as bipolar disorder), amiodarone (heart medication with high iodine content), and some newer cancer immunotherapies can interfere with proper thyroid function. 
• The iodine paradox: Iodine is vital for thyroid hormone production, but it’s needed in the right amounts, as too much or too little can lead to thyroid dysfunction. Severe iodine deficiency is a significant cause of hypothyroidism worldwide, but excess can also trigger or worsen hypothyroidism, particularly in people with existing autoimmune disorders. In certain scenarios, high iodine intake may even serve as the catalyst that triggers an autoimmune response. 
• Congenital hypothyroidism: People with the condition are born with a dysplastic (underdeveloped) or missing thyroid gland. 
• Transient thyroiditis: This refers to a temporary dip in thyroid function that’s caused by subacute thyroiditis, a viral infection, or postpartum hormonal shifts. 

The Classic Lab Pattern: TSH on Fire

Some of the classic patterns that show up in TSH blood test results of patients diagnosed with primary hypothyroidism include: 

• High TSH: This is considered to be one of the primary signs of an underproducing thyroid, as it indicates that the pituitary gland is working diligently to restore normal hormone production. However, the complex feedback loop means that high TSH does not always equate to being a clear sign of an underproducing thyroid.
• Low Free T4: This confirms that the thyroid gland isn’t responding adequately, despite the high TSH levels signaling the need for T4 production. This does not necessarily mean that the thyroid gland is damaged or incapable of producing T4, as in one example, excess iodine intake can cause anti-TPO antibodies in the Wolff-Chaikoff effect, limiting T4 production as the body attempts to prevent hyperthyroidism from occurring.
• Normal T3 levels: This is an often misunderstood metric. T3 is more metabolically active than T4, and the body prioritizes converting any available T4 into T3 to protect vital functions like heart rate, brain function, and temperature regulation. This means T3 levels can remain stable long after T4 levels drop. 

The high TSH, low free T4 pattern is what most endocrinologists are trained to look for. The standard treatment is to replace the missing T4 with levothyroxine (synthetic T4). However, many endocrinologists over-focus on TSH and still medicate a slightly high TSH with levothyroxine even if free T4 levels are already normal. Beyond this, this oversimplified care model falls apart even more when the thyroid gland isn’t the source of the problem.

Secondary Hypothyroidism: A Breakdown in Communication

Secondary hypothyroidism, also known as central hypothyroidism, is a lot trickier to address. In these cases, the thyroid gland is perfectly capable of producing T4 and T3, but it’s not getting the right inputs. The problem typically lies in the command center, the pituitary gland, or the hypothalamus beyond it. 

What Causes Secondary Hypothyroidism? It Starts in the Brain.

Some of the common causes of secondary hypothyroidism include:

• Pituitary tumors (adenomas): Functioning and non-functioning tumors can grow and compress healthy pituitary tissues, disrupting TSH production. Pituitary tumor hypothyroidism is a classic manifestation of the disease. 
• Pituitary surgery or radiation: Surgeries and radiation treatments performed on the thyroid gland can damage areas vital for hormone production. 
• Head trauma: A major blow to the head can cause bleeding in the thyroid gland or shear the delicate pituitary stalk. 
• Infiltrative diseases: Conditions like sarcoidosis, hemochromatosis, or histiocytosis can hinder pituitary function. 
• Sheehan’s syndrome: Severe blood loss and shock during childbirth can permanently damage pituitary tissue. 
• Genetic disorders: Rare genetic mutations can affect the development and function of the pituitary gland. 

The Overlooked Link: Spinal CSF Leaks and Pituitary Compression

This is a critical factor that mainstream endocrinology often misses when diagnosing secondary hypothyroidism. 

A spinal cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leak causes low volume inside the skull, which can lead to the brain sagging downward, a condition called intracranial hypovolemia. The brain then ends up compressing the pituitary gland against the sella turcica–the bony saddle that holds the gland, disrupting its ability to produce TSH. 

In many cases of a spinal CSF leak, the pituitary gland might show up as enlarged and engorged on a brain MRI. However, in some cases, the gland is partially or fully flattened, often due to the descent of the hindbrain interrupting CSF flow and causing CSF to accumulate in certain areas in uneven distribution around the brain. This compression can directly disrupt the pituitary gland’s ability to produce TSH. 

Let’s discuss the case of a spinal leak patient with a flattened pituitary gland to drive our point home. Her lab results showed low TSH and low T4, which is standard for central hypothyroidism, but her T3 levels were normal. The physicians decided to avoid medication and instead addressed the root cause. 

They treated her spinal leak with an epidural blood patch to seal the leak, providing full buoyancy to her brain that made her hindbrain float back up and stop acting as a partial stopper, and thus relieved the pressure that was flattening her pituitary gland. Follow-up tests showed her TSH and T4 levels quickly returned to normal ranges, showing her thyroid problems were caused by the uneven CSF flow around her brain, physically compressing her pituitary gland, not an issue within the gland itself. 

This raises the question of whether the high rate of undiagnosed spinal leaks, sometimes stemming from routine medical procedures such as labor epidurals, could be silently contributing to unexplained secondary hypothyroidism. This patient’s recovery journey underscores that secondary hypothyroidism is sometimes a mechanical problem that requires a mechanical fix. 

The Puzzling Lab Pattern: When TSH Levels Don’t Tell the Entire Story

Diagnosing secondary hypothyroidism starts with recognizing a lab pattern that defies the primary model. Here’s what it often looks like:

• TSH: Low TSH levels are a significant red flag that can signal a damaged pituitary gland that can’t produce enough TSH.  A damaged gland might produce a tiny bit of TSH, none, or a defective hormone molecule that shows up on tests but doesn’t trigger T4 production. 
• Low Free T4: A healthy thyroid underproduces T4 when it's not getting strong signals from the pituitary gland. 
• Normal T3 levels: The body’s preservation mechanism kicks in when it senses thyroid dysfunction, converting any T4 available into T3. 

This pattern of a low free T4 paired with inappropriately low or normal TSH highlights the flaw in primarily focusing on TSH when screening for hypothyroidism. Interestingly, in the spinal leak patient’s case, while her TSH was non-detectable, her T4 was barely below the normal range the researchers used, and her T3 levels were still within normal range. 

An endocrinologist might over-fixate on TSH levels and even attempt to label this as hyperthyroidism. One article published on the American Academy of Family Physicians’ (AAFP) site stated that subclinical hyperthyroidism involves a low or undetectable TSH and a normal T4 and normal T3. The patients’ symptoms are important here as hyperthyroidism and hypothyroidism can often feel different, with increased hunger, weight loss, increased heart rate, a feeling of high energy, and other such symptoms reported for hyperthyroidism and decreased hunger, decreased heart rate, weight gain, constipation, fatigue, and other such symptoms reported for hypothyroidism. 

However, these symptoms vary for everyone. Part of the issue here as well is the labeling of “normal range” free T4, as the range is fairly wide for normal, and a low-normal T4 with an undetectable TSH is a much more suspicious presentation for potential central hypothyroidism than an undetectable TSH with a high-normal T4. 

Having personally had an undetectable TSH with a high-normal T4, this only occurred once my free T4 had lowered from months of climbing up to an extremely high number. My free T4 had to reach this high number over time before my TSH then finally became fully suppressed and thereby undetectable. Once my free T4 had lowered into the high-normal range, my TSH quickly surged and was detectable again. While every human is individual, having seen these tendencies personally, I would encourage patients to question their physician if they have a low-normal T4 and normal T3 and an undetectable TSH that is labeled as subclinical hyperthyroidism to ask how biologically a low-normal T4 could manage to suppress TSH production.   

Subclinical hyperthyroidism, as described by the AAFP, makes more sense as a transitional state from overt hyperthyroidism back to euthyroidism, where past sustained high free T4 levels can suppress TSH, which often does not resurface until the free T4 is then brought back down to normal levels. At that point, the patient is still technically chemically hyperthyroid with a normal free T4 and an undetectable TSH. 

However, the patient moving from a normal thyroid status to an undetectable TSH and a normal T4 should raise some eyebrows. In cases of iodine-induced hyperthyroidism or levothyroxine-induced hyperthyroidism, there often is a sudden onset where free T4 jumps. Based on patient reporting of labs and anecdotes, it typically takes duration and sustained elevation of free T4 to lower TSH, with the TSH being a hormone that lags behind T4 production in reaction. That is why patients with sudden-onset hyperthyroid-like symptoms might have a TSH of any number with a sudden jump of free T4 over upper normal limits, such as a normal TSH with a free T4 of 2 ng/dl (normal range differs by lab but given sometimes as 0.8-1.8 ng/dl).

Symptoms and sequences of events are important. At times, endocrinologists may dismiss patients’ experiences, missing the important fact that low or low-normal T4 levels, along with a low TSH, could be indicative instead of secondary hypothyroidism rather than subclinical hyperthyroidism. 

A more effective approach might be to order a full thyroid panel and a pituitary MRI when such patterns are noticed. Is the pituitary compressed with empty sella syndrome or partial empty sella syndrome noted? Such an assessment would look at the cause of TSH suppression as being physical pressure on the pituitary gland rather than free T4 being high enough to suppress TSH production. Has the patient had a sudden-onset headache or any other neurological symptoms and/or any type of spinal procedure such as an epidural steroid injection in pain management, a labor epidural during birth, or spinal anesthesia during surgery? These could hint at the onset of a spontaneous or iatrogenic (medical injury) spinal leak leading to a compressed pituitary with interrupted CSF flow leading to central hypothyroidism. 

Primary vs. Secondary Hypothyroidism: A Side-by-Side Breakdown

Here’s a table that highlights the key differences between primary and secondary hypothyroidism:

The Diagnostic Journey: Connecting Symptoms to Source

Primary and secondary hypothyroidism share many classic symptoms like fatigue, unexplained weight loss, cold intolerance, dry skin, hair loss, brain fog, and depression. However, secondary hypothyroidism can potentially add unique symptoms that point to a central problem. Of course, there is always the potential for these symptoms to be caused in primary hypothyroidism cases due to a different cascade of events such as disruption in vitamin and mineral absorption causing hormonal imbalances or dehydration headaches from primary hypothyroidism affecting vision further when stacked on top of migraines. The question always is what is leading to what.

Potential Sequences for Symptoms within Secondary Hypothyroidism

Since the pituitary gland also manages other hormonal axes, dysfunction there can lead to additional symptoms like:

• Headaches or vision changes due to a pituitary tumor pressing on nerves
• Loss of menstrual periods, infertility, or low libido
• Unexpected weakness, dizziness, and low blood pressure 
• Positional headaches that intensify when upright, potentially due to a spinal leak
• Neck stiffness 
• Tinnitus

Thyroid Function Test Interpretation: Primary vs Secondary Hypothyroidism Scenarios

Let’s explore three common scenarios to paint a clearer picture of how thyroid function tests should be interpreted:

Primary hypothyroidism: TSH = 12 mIU/L (high), Free T4 = 0.7 ng/dL (low). 

Interpretation: The thyroid is failing. The high TSH confirms the pituitary is responding appropriately to low T4, but the thyroid is still not capable of creating enough free T4. 

Secondary hypothyroidism: TSH = 1.8 mIU/L ("normal"), Free T4 = 0.7 ng/dL (low). 

Interpretation: There’s a major disconnect. Think of the relationship between the pituitary and thyroid glands as a thermostat used to regulate an air conditioner, respectively. A normal thermostat setting should lead to a normal temperature in the area. If the area is hot but the thermostat isn’t calling for more cooling when set on normal, it’s probably malfunctioning. 

The confusing middle ground: TSH = 5.5 mIU/L (mildly high), Free T4 = 1.0 ng/dL (low-normal). 

Interpretation: This is usually called "subclinical hypothyroidism." It might point to early primary hypothyroidism, but it could also signify secondary hypothyroidism or other causes, such as the body attempting to modulate in response to too much dietary iodine intake, potentially over months or years. Context and sometimes further assessments are needed to pinpoint root causes. 

Treatment Paths: Why One Size Does NOT Fit All

Is levothyroxine used for secondary hypothyroidism treatment? Yes, levothyroxine (T4) can be used as a treatment for both types of hypothyroidism, but with very different management philosophies. 

Levothyroxine is titrated to normalize TSH levels when treating primary hypothyroidism, where the T4 levels might already be normal, while the focus in secondary hypothyroidism is on normalizing T4 levels since the damaged or suppressed pituitary glands are not providing accurate feedback.

Of note here, as mentioned already, levothyroxine has already been observed as possibly not needed in approximately 90% of cases by Yale. For patients with normal T4 levels and slightly high TSH levels in primary hypothyroidism, these patients can self-advocate for further investigation into the root cause, such as evaluating dietary iodine intake. 

Likewise, for patients with potential secondary hypothyroidism with a low free T4 and an undetectable TSH, going into hyperthyroidism when medicated with levothyroxine is a major concern without TSH being present to help modulate T4. It is important for these patients to track their symptoms and to ask their physicians to help ascertain the severity of their condition, such as the potential for a myxedema coma, a medical emergency with confusion, hypothermia, slow heart rate, and multi-organ failure, usually triggered by infection or stress in someone with untreated hypothyroidism. 

The patient keeping track of body temperature, heart rate, and so on is crucial to assessing risk. This can give more input on whether there is time to investigate a fixable root cause further before immediately jumping to treatment. 

Can You Have Both? Unraveling Complex Cases

Wondering if you can have both primary and secondary hypothyroidism? It’s an extremely rare occurrence. What’s more likely to occur is other existing health issues mimicking or adding to your thyroid problem.

The example of a patient with central hypothyroidism caused by a spinal leak we used earlier is a prime example of how existing issues can make interpreting thyroid test results confusing. For example, a patient might have a history of Hashimoto’s contributing to primary hypothyroidism and then develop a spinal leak that flattens their pituitary gland, adding a central component.

Moving Beyond the TSH Blind Spot

Understanding the differences between primary vs secondary hypothyroidism starts with recognizing that the simplistic "high TSH = hypothyroidism" and “low TSH = hyperthyroidism” model has many cracks. This model already fails many primary hypothyroidism patients and can potentially misdiagnose patients with secondary hypothyroidism with subclinical hyperthyroidism without physicians possessing a better understanding of the feedback mechanisms along the Hypothalamic-Pituitary-Thyroid axis (HPT) and how these hormones interact with each other.

To self-advocate, ask questions like "What is my Free T4 value?" if a physician tells you your thyroid is functioning correctly based on TSH levels alone. You could actually have a normal TSH level but a low free T4 or a high free T4, which would indicate the need for further investigation. Ask for a full thyroid and pituitary panel and request an MRI to rule out structural issues, such as pituitary gland concerns. Ask your physician to explain the hormonal mechanisms within the Hypothalamic-Pituitary-Thyroid axis (HPT) and what particular cascade of events they think is occurring in your case. They should have a logical understanding of cause-and-effect sequences to assess for risk-benefit analyses and provide effective care.   

The path to managing hypothyroidism correctly starts with understanding how the entire Hypothalamic-Pituitary-Thyroid (HPT) Axis works, including the pituitary gland’s role in sending out instructions, the feedback loop between the thyroid and pituitary, and how external factors like spinal leaks can impact thyroid function. It demands looking deeper than the first line of a lab report. 

Tired of Oversimplified Answers to Your Complex Health Concerns?

The conventional model used to diagnose primary vs secondary hypothyroidism often misses the nuances we’ve explored here. Try a different approach if you’re dealing with symptoms like fatigue, brain fog, and sensitivity to cold, but your doctors dismiss your complaints because of normal lab results. 

Watch our course, Are You Consuming Too Much Iodine? Excess Intake & Thyroid Disorders, to learn more about the nuances of hypothyroidism in the context of complex cases potentially exacerbated by patients not staying within the U-curve of benefit for dietary iodine intake. Use this course as a starting point for self-advocacy.  

We partner with clinicians worldwide to analyze complex real-world cases, such as spinal leak-induced thyroid dysfunction, and discuss the latest research. We also integrate global perspectives on root-cause medicine, which is often missing in the U.S. healthcare system. Subscribe to our newsletter for regular updates.